Like many of you, I have been following the Mary Winkler murder trial (the minister's wife who killed her husband) with a great deal of interest. I went to the same college (now a university) that Mary and Matthew Winker attended, and I’ve met Matthew Winkler’s grandfather. So this is one of those news stories to which I have paid particular attention. I have been a bit chagrined, though not surprised, that some in the media have turned this case into a referendum on what’s wrong with conservative churches and religion in general. The idea seems to be that there had to be some dark secret caused by and covered up because of the church that led to this crime. If Matthew Winker had been a doctor, I wonder if the same kind of scrutiny would have gone into the pressure of being a physicians wife?
Tressa called me upset the other day. She had been unable to sleep and caught the Nancy Grace show on CNN. Grace was interviewing my former professor Rubel Shelly and the question was, “Is the church of Christ a cult?” Grace really didn’t want to learn anything from Rubel; she barely even let him talk. After reading the transcript of the show, I think Rubel did about as well as he could given the stacked deck. This line of questioning was generated by the previous night’s show in which grace interviewed (in a much more civil way) a Baptist pastor named Tom Rukala. Here’s a portion of that interview--
RUKALA: Well, the Church of Christ is a relatively new church. It was started about 150 years ago by Alexander Campbell. And it’s, unfortunately, a very legalistic sect, and they tend to use methods of intimidation and pressure tactics. They claim that they are the only ones going to heaven, and all other people are condemned to hell… They claim that if you’re not baptized by one of their ministers, that you’re doomed to hell, even if you’re a believer in Jesus Christ, which, of course, breaks completely from the traditional Christian view that all those who call upon the name of the Lord Jesus Christ will be saved because we’re saved by grace through faith in Jesus Christ, who died for our sins and rose again. For the Church of Christ folks, that’s not enough. You have to be a member of their narrow sect. It’s a very exclusive group. And if you’re not a member of their sect, you’re condemned.
GRACE: You know, Pastor, you keep saying “sect.” “Sect.” You make it sound
like a cult.
RUKALA: It kind of is a borderline cult, unfortunately. I don’t want to make it out to be some kind of Hare Krishna group, but it has cult-like characteristics and...
GRACE: In what sense?
RUKALA: Well, in the sense of the exclusivism, the attitude that they are the only ones who know the truth. The tactics that they use are sometimes just -- not only un-biblical but unethical, and they can be very ungracious, unfortunately.
It can be eye-opening and a bit distressing to hear yourself characterized through the eyes of others. Rukaka's characterization is certainly not accurate for all Churches of Christ; it is not accurate for me or for my church. Unfortunately, he is right on the money for many churches among us. There is a legalistic and exclusivistic strand that is woven through our heritage. It is time to put that behind us and get back to being what we once were—a unity movement.
1 comment:
Thanks for the posting. I have Tom Ruhkala's e-mail address posted on my blog. You might want to write him a note. I'm encouraging everyone I know in the COC to write to him and aplologize to him for how he and others have been treated by COCers over the years.
Post a Comment