Thursday, October 16, 2008

Reflections on the Debate

I participated in a public debate in West Virginia when I was in grad school. No, I wasn’t the disputant (the one debating) or the moderator (the one officiating). I wasn’t even the time-keeper (the one, well, keeping time). I was the guy who sat up on the stage with the overhead projector flashing the slides when one or the other called out, “May I see Slide #317J please.” There were hundreds of slides, so this was actually a big job. Maybe my subsequent fascination with PowerPoint was born on that polemic platform!

The debate got pretty ugly pretty quickly. The moderators kept jumping in with “point of order” objections. The disputants constantly tried to outdo one another’s sarcasm, even to the point of drawing cartoon caricatures of each other on their slides. (Of course, the slides were flashed on the screen with a crisp and professional efficiency). At one point, the disputants called each other “the devil.” After the debate was over, both sides claimed that great victories had been won for the cause of truth. Actually, people came away from the debate having what they believed before the debate confirmed and reinforced. I remember the whole thing being rather embarrassing.

I watched part of the Obama-McCain debate last night.  So... what did we learn from the debate? McCain is feisty.  Obama is smooth?  That each of them has “a plan” to make things better.., though they are hazy on exactly what those things are.  Surely, the only people coming out of that debate with strong feelings for one candidate or another were people who had gone into the debate with those strong feelings.  

My take on the debate is summed up by this clip from Pat Paulsen and his presidential run back in 1968.  Paulsen was a comedian whose satire on the political process often hit pretty close to home.    He also perfected the ability to talk out of both sides of his mouth.  And is it just me, or did Paulson look a lot like Ron Paul... who also may still be running for president somewhere?


8 comments:

same said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
same said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
same said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
same said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
same said...

Hay, I did the same thing in sixth grade. . . however the slides were in order (as they were on a roll) and there was an annoying beep on the cassette tape and the annoying prompting of the openly democratic, atheistic, cynical teachers raspy voice as she said from behind a cloud of smoke, “time for the next slide, please!” (she was puffing on a cancer stick near an open window and I do not think she will be reading your blog where she is, (Well. . . I hope not anyway). haven't seen that "Appropriate Video", special effects very good for it's day.

I am sure I am not alone when I say, We do not like what we have seen, as we have watched the way those who would be our national leaders have conducted their campaigns. Having seen a number of presidential debates I thought this one would be carried on with more dignity and good manners. Yet it quickly feel into a down hill polemic spiral and is need of reformation from both sides.

same said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
same said...

Yet there is that problem of inexpedience in the executive branch and that coupled with other things disqualifies at least one of those running for that most high office from getting my vote. (Poor choice of parties is another story). That is a real problem coupled with his young age and that lipstick on a pig comment (WHAT WAS HE THINKING).

That heart beat away thing will mean that ‘that women’, the possible right hand person to the president, will have to be trained to fill in for her would be boss very quickly should anything happen to incapacitate him as is more likely at his ‘golden age’. WOW, I would say he has weathered the storms well! Those silver threads on his head are numbered as are his days, (he is a loving father and husband who is not afraid to suffer and sacrifice for the love of others who are in need) that and his lifelong associates support of him say more about the man’s character and experience than I will ever know. The negative propaganda I have heard, I am familiar with the hateful lies laid down by the enemies of our nation. False witnesses are nothing new and they will not be able to hide in the shadows forever.

Truth is patent, kind and long suffering, yet it will not be forever. Truth will have it’s say, the thunder will role as the lighting will flash and the liars will tremble and all will fall to their knees as all they are is exposed. For what they have done they can not undo. They have committed themselves to evil and with evil they will dwell forever.
Should the man become president I would say, “No more than three or four 12 ounce beers a week and since I know one beer makes me drunk (if I drink it all), don’t ever drink more than half a beer or a few ounces of wine at one meal. Or better yet, If you don’t have to drink, don’t, and your judgement and sobriety will never be in question as others will have to smell your breath that you have breathed and the sweet that you have sweated.”
I do believe both sides made a lot of mistakes and both sides have much to offer.

same said...

Nuclear energy should only be used where there is no other way. It is expensive and very dangerous with long tern disposal problems. There are ships that are so hot they will have to be sunk where the earths crust comes together and heads toward the center of the great flaming crucible that we live on (for the sake of future generations we must look toward a better (and less toxic) place for them to live. We all want what is best for our children but not at the expense of the poor among us. We are no more important than the rest of the world. All that junk has to go somewhere and it is not right to put it into someone else’s back yard. There are those who are greedy pigs and dogs and they will if allowed to. . . ruin the earth for those who are not yet born..